« Fishnet Organizations - Temporary and Flexible Hierarchies | Main | The Social Business Edge ... Stowe Boyd »
Tuesday
Jan262010

Exploring the HR Management Framework for Enterprise 2.0

(cross-posted at the FASTForward blog)

The title is a dead giveaway, and I am using the term 'framework' loosely.  Why ?

Because I think no one really knows what a large-scale transition to social computing and collaboration as core work activities really means for today's (and tomorrow's) human resources professionals and the management processes and practices they design, implement, coach and manage.

I say that with full knowledge that the last two decades have seen a lot of talk and activity aimed at 'modernizing' human resources management practices.  There have been regular clarion calls for major change, and waves of interest and activity aimed at transforming HR professionals to become (for example):

  • business partners with line management

  • proactive change agents

  • coaches to managers and professionals

  • enablers of change, as opposed to (more traditional) gatekeeper roles


... but really, in spite of the last two decades replete with talks, books, workshops and consulting about learning organizations, high-performance work environments, knowledge-work or customer-service friendly organizational cultures and so on, the basics of human resources management goals and practices have remained little changed, philosophically and practically.

The main metaphor today's HR professionals live in is still a machine with its designed-and-fitted parts and cogs, as opposed to the 'living' system of social networks in which people participate and interact.  This dominant metaphor leads to language such as optimization, alignment, productivity and control.

Let me be clear ... in an enterprise setting, these are unequivocally good things to seek and realize.  However, the basic vocabulary of intention, methods and practices that can create these characteristics in a networked environment may be different.  In electronically connected networks where we "work at the speed of light" (McLuhan), different thinking and ways of working are necessary, and a new vocabulary may be very useful with respect to advancing on what we now have and use.

Talent Wars and Computers-Everywhere Meet the Era of Social Networks

The notion of purposeful social computing in and by workers (and customers) in an enterprise setting developed out of the rise and growth of what has come to be known as Web 2.0, and was termed Enterprise 2.0 about three and a half years ago.  Given that it arose from the welter of confusing-to-many activities that defined web 2.0 (Participation, interaction and sharing) I have often wondered if the term itself has been more of a hindrance than a help when making decisions about whether, why and how to put social computing and the potential of social networks into play in any given organization.

However, the term is here to stay, and acquires more and more legitimacy all the time, thanks largely to the pioneering work of several thought-and-practice leaders and an excellent summary of the issues and examples to date in a new book titled Enterprise 2.0 - New Collaborative Tools for Your Enterprise's Toughest Challenges, by Andrew McAfee (widely known as coiner of the term "Enterprise 2.0"

So ... what about HR 2.0 for the Enterprise 2.0 ?

Human resources management is basically about finding, attracting, engaging, motivating, and retaining (helping to grow / evolve ?) the best available talent.  In an era increasingly defined by information, knowledge and more recently participation, engagement, relationships, influence, etc., people who are talented, imaginative, creative, honest and hard-working often remain an elusive and slippery target.

Much of the foundation for modern human resources management frameworks and established practices comes directly out of the 50's and 60's (yes, including more recent competency analysis and modelling and self-directed work groups, etc.) and is firmly grounded in mainstream management models.  Two major waves that sought to review and revise the established practices came with the debate (70's and early 80's) over Theory X and Theory Y management philosophies, and the basic steps taken in the 90's and 2000's to recognize that the enterprise's future involves different kinds of knowledge workers than those who dominated over the past40 years.

In my opinion, the issues have become more complex over the past five years.  Many of the established HR methods and practices depend upon the foundations of traditional management science, and plain and simply did not foresee the rise of pervasive and ubiquitous socially-connected workplaces.

Let's look at each of the main areas of HR, and make some educated guesses as to how the interconnected 2.0 context may affect HR methods and practices.

Recruitment

Recruitment is about attracting, finding, wooing and checking out talent - it's the courtship before the relationship begins.

This area of HR felt the dramatic impact of the Web early, in the form of job boards.  Job boards and template-based resumes became the norm pretty quickly, given the efficiencies introduced for busy HR people concerned with the first steps of recruitment.

There are / were disadvantages, however.  Keyword-constrained templates and functionality of most job boards ensured two things; 1) that some interesting and potentially very valuable candidates would be screened out because the match wasn't precise enough, and 2) many people would be screened in (by using appropriate keywords) who did not really belong in the given recruitment process.

As web use and the presence and population of social networking platforms has grown, new dynamics have appeared in recruitment.  LinkedIn is a source of much activity, as is the more 'organic' word-of-mouth recommendation of people by people who know them.  This latter dynamic is, in my opinion, the really important one here.  It's how people operate, and networking to find new work or a more interesting job, or just to make a change, was well underway long before Web 2.0 came around.  The Web has just made it ... easier, faster and more effective.

I expect before long that people will offer potential employers as many references from people they know and have worked / interacted with on the Web as they will from former employers and colleagues.

Employee Orientation

Employee orientation is all about helping new employees "get their feet under the desk". Supplementing job descriptions and the expectations agreed to upon hiring, an early response to the challenge was the use of an enterprise intranet, with which to support all the information new employees needed to know.

However, the real work of getting ones' feet under the desk requires participation, interaction and 'learning the ropes', and here it's clear that joining into the flow(s) operating in social networks inside an enterprise can be very useful with respect to a new employee's more rapid and more effective orientation.  Many (all ?) of the collaboration / social computing platforms offer features such as profiles, personal tag clouds, and other contextual information that is crucial to effective orientation.

Work Design (Job descriptions)

Here's an area that I suspect will come under a fair degree of scrutiny as the adoption and traction of Enterprise 2.0 continues to grow.  Job descriptions have a bad rep, and yet are essential in modern organizations, even if they are short and sweet.

The issue?  If they are short and sweet, they tend (in my experience) to be found in organizations that are already by and large nimble, adaptive and probably pretty well suited to operating in today's networked environment.  They are an (but not THE) indicator of less bureaucratic organizations.

However, in many more structure or more bureaucratic organizations, they have become an input and an emblem of power and status, in the sense that their main purpose is often to help peg a job's position in the organizational hierarchy and the salary, benefits and other perquisites obtained by the job.

As jobs in the modern world change rapidly and pretty regularly, there's been growing (but often slow) interest in what I call role profiles.  As an aside, I was just last night reading a lecture delivered in 1974 by Marshall McLuhan (mentioned above) in which he noted that the notion of 'job' in an electronic era was a relic of a bygone era; in the more rapid electronic environment, he said, we are more clearly engaged in role-playing than we are in carrying out the task of a 'job'.  1974 !!

A well-crafted role profile need be no longer than one page (landscape) and can include all of the essential information (including competencies and learning objectives) related to a given role.

Job descriptions are likely to remain an issue in many organizations getting involved with Enterpise 2.0 initiatives, as it will take some learning and experience to know what will be the effect on the concept of a 'job' from people operating constantly in a socially-networked environment

Employee Performance

Performance management has been a hot-button issue in most enterprises for a long time.  At its best, a well-designed and disciplined approach to performance management can play a positive and constructive role in delivering sustained high performance, and can be central to creating a performance oriented culture in the enterprise.

All too often, however, performance management schemes serve to remind us that too many workplaces are the adult version of grade school, with report cards and a parent-like boss who has unwanted power over employee's future and fate.

360-degree feedback processes (soliciting input on performance from subordinates, colleagues, superiors and even external customers and liaisons) have been around long enough now to have most of the kinks worked out, and are probably a decent pre-cursor to forms of 'crowdsourcing' input on employees' performance.  Many (most ?) of the social computing / collaboration platforms out there have features and functionality designed to offer support to gathering and processing information about peoples' performance.

The culture of an enterprise is an all-important aspect of why and how performance management is used.  I expect that this aspect will become more important as social computing and collaboration continues to grow and spread.

Training & Development

Too big a subject area to deal with here.  Suffice it to say that this is an area that has over the past five years or so generated a wholesale review of T & D philosophies and activities.  Much of the discussion is aimed at assessing how effective formal learning / T & D has been, and why and how informal, or social, learning is so pervasive and so important.

This issue gets at the heart of why social computing and collaboration is a big deal, and is (probably) changing the nature of knowledge work in today's interconnected environment.

It's important to note here that there will (IMO) always be an important role for structured formal training & development / learning focused on specific aspects of the kinds of information and knowledge needed by workers.  It's also probably the case that much or all of that type of learning will be available online, and offered in various hybrid combinations of virtual and F2F learning environments.

For a concise yet comprehensive summary of the core issues and why the impact of the Web is so important in this area, see my colleague Harold Jarche's "Social Learning in the Enterprise".

Reward & Remuneration

Where to start ?

In many of my writings about social computing, collaboration, Enterprise 2.0, hierarchy and wirearchy, I have stated that the enterprise-driven process of job evaluation is a real and ever-present challenge to the effectiveness of Enterprise 2.0 adoption and effectiveness.

In a vast general sense, levels of remuneration for many types of jobs are determined by job evaluation, a process of 'measuring' the amount of knowledge, problem-solving and accountability contained in a job.  There are of course other influences like union contracts on specific industries, 'hot' (or currently-in-demand) skills, local and regional issues, and so on ... but there is clearly stratification in the levels of pay and compensation depending upon the type(s) of work.

Not only that, there is important legislation in many of the developed countries governing the issue(s) of Equal Pay for Work of Equal Value that specifies in general terms how the worth of a job is measured and what the issues are for setting remuneration levels for types of work

Remuneration is a subject area that is too vast (and too arcane) to get into here, but it's one that I expect will experience more and more change as the era of social computing and social networks in the workplace really gets going.

I have some ideas on the evolution of this area of HR, mainly gleaned from work I have done in the past on 1) competency-based pay and 2) contribution-based pay.

And, to revive a term I have not heard much of for the past 15 years or so, might Enterprise 2.0 help rejuvenate the concept of gainsharing ?

Administrative

Most administrative issues and practices in the HR field were automated in HRIS systems at least a decade ago, if not longer.  I am not aware of how Enterprise 2.0 would visit any change to this area of HR management.

.

This is already a too-long post.  And, I have not even touched on the ways HR professionals need to change what and how they deliver to meet the challenges posed by Enterprise 2.0.

As noted at the beginning of this piece, I am not aware of significant work in the general area of changes to mainstream HR practices as a result of embarking on the path towards Enterprise 2.0.  I will be delighted to learn from any of you of examples and / or issues I may have missed or glossed over.

.

References (1)

References allow you to track sources for this article, as well as articles that were written in response to this article.
  • Response
    Response: Pretty good post
    I just stumbled upon your website and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts. Any way I'll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon.

Reader Comments (91)

Hi Jon

This is a cracking post. Thank you.

I really like your critique of job descriptions and concept of role profiles. Role profiles are new to me and in my minds eye I see them as negotiated, dynamic, and updatable on a wiki.

January 26, 2010 | Unregistered Commenteranne marie mcewan

Role profiles are new to me and in my minds eye I see them as negotiated, dynamic, and updatable on a wiki.

Pretty much exactly right, Anne Marie.

There are some other pretty interesting and simple 'tools' for designing work , such as accountability mapping by a team or work group, that have in my opinion been much overlooked. Maybe we should talk about them someday ?

January 26, 2010 | Unregistered Commenteradmin

[...] Shared Exploring the HR Management Framework for Enterprise 2.0. [...]

[...] Wirearchy · Exploring the HR Management Framework for Enterprise 2.0Jon Husband writes on the impact of Web 2.0 on traditional HR structures and processeswirearchy HR OD web2.0 enterprise2.0 [...]

January 31, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterSynesthesia

Hi Jon.

Getting HR to re-tool for E.20, I believe, is crucial to reaching out to the majority of 'late adopter' employees within any business. If the non-social among us see that their performance reviews can be positively influenced by participating and collaborating, then they are more likely to do so.

Certain ECM platforms have a weighted points system based on the various kinds of activities people can perform on an enterprise community. Some also come with content analysis reporting mechanisms which can drill down to view the contributions of individuals - important for assessing the quality of member activities.

If HR departments don't move on with the times, they can be the anchor that drags E2.0 iniatives to a halt and, in some cases, cause them to fail. Great post Jon, ambitious too.

February 9, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterMichael Ricard

Michael, thanks for stopping by and my apologies for the tardy reply to your comment. I am still getting used to my new site and blogging platform.

If HR departments don't move on with the times, they can be the anchor that drags E2.0 iniatives to a halt and, in some cases, cause them to fail.

I think that's very real risk, and it's also clear that HR (and IT and line management()can play a very important role in work design and organizational structure for the networked organization.

In fact, they have to. The Web and social computing, collaboration platforms and social networking in and across the organization, and its markets, are here to stay. It will only get more intense and more pervasive, and it WILL eventually become the ecosystem of information-knowledge-social-connections-and-interlinked-searchable-databases that we are all so intrigued by. The promise is enormous --- for good and also for bad or undesirable. The challenges are many. The need for a new paradigm has never been clearer, the signals are everywhere flashing orange. The pressures and the examples of why its needed and have been building up for some time.

N doubt we'll see what happens and whatever any coherent general framework framework evolves will be fraught with human foibles and wrangling over power, status and money. I also think the concepts of intellectual and social capital and socially or co-created economic and tangible social / community value will have to emerge

February 11, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterJon Husband

Ugg, a legendary brand, the first thing people see snow boots, Ugg are a bit clumsy and cartoons on the shape do not like, but it is such a boot, since many European and American stars are wearing Ugg snow to look pretty and popular boots in Europe and America, Ugg whipped up a pop style.In our website www.ugg-bootsuk.org/ you can have more choices, such as
ugg classic short boots
ugg classic short
classic short boots
classic short
ugg classic mini boots
ugg classic mini
classic mini boots
Many people like to cosplay, for example to play the hero role in the movie, here we meet you, and the price is cheap, we have various styles of clothing, such as:
lolita dress
lolita dresses
gothic lolita dress
gothic lolita dresses
full body spandex suit
full body suit
Moreover, we also provide Stylish and beautiful wedding, such as:
white wedding dresses
white wedding dress
white bridal gowns
white wedding gowns
white bridal dresses
gold wedding dresses
gold wedding dress
gold bridal gowns
gold wedding gowns
gold bridal dresses
Celebrity Evening Dresses

October 17, 2010 | Unregistered Commenterdiscount ugg boots

There are many flat irons?that are made from ceramic plates on the market. The Chi hair straightener is a good choice. Chi straightener has become one of the most popular brands that is the favorite and unique choice of many trendy ladies.People use metallic flat irons that can cause dangerous effects on their hair before the introduction of CHI iron.With the development of modern science and technology, many premier hairstyling products are manufactured, CHI flat iron is one of the best.Don't hesitate to ask questions before buying them at CHI outlet.

October 18, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterCHI OUTLET

Hello, im new here and found this Blog is intresting. I am going to contribute here and hopefully stick around! just though id say hello.

Thanks Alot.

October 26, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterGemsonline

This information for all people around the world.
http://www.genericdrugshop.info/

October 26, 2010 | Unregistered Commentercreation2u

buy allegra online
http://www.sundrugstore.com

October 29, 2010 | Unregistered Commenterbuy allegra online

href="http://www.feetlockers.com/reebok-easytone-c-25.html">Reebok ZigTech tests the shoes on real runners who fill in a detailed questionnaire at the start, mid-way and end of 300-mile increments. They’re light, flexible and so comfortable. Reebok ZigTech shoes footwear, training longer just got easier.Reebok Easytone Shoes has the top technology which uses shoes’ energy and transfers it horizontally. ZigTech helps to transfer weight through the whole range of motion by pushing the force of the strike through to the front of your foot. Discount Reebok zigtech footwear is designed to protect your feet and return energy to the athlete for a soft and springy ride. The foam is lightweight. Forefoot flex grooves for added Reebok EasyTone flexibility. This ultimately enables athletes to stay healthier during in this season.

October 30, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterReebok EasyTone

href="http://www.zigtechshoesonsale.com/mbt-women-shoes-c-15.html">MBT Shoes healthy shoes discount mbt shoes are designed for anyone’s foot.Cheap mbt shoes is not too high, if the heel is higher than 3.5 cm, it will increase the risk of lumbar lordosis and lumbosacral angle, which easily lead to fatigue and lower back pain and lumbosacral joint.Moreover, the girls who wear high heels early will lead to Discount Mbt Shoes the developing pelvic tilt, which make the Mbt shoes clearance, is demanding.However, they are not only for people on their feet but for anyone who wants to wear a pair of comfortable Mbt shoes outlet that takes the pain away from your body when you are standing and walking. That’s why you need to wear MBT Sandals Shoes.

October 30, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterDiscount Mbt Shoes

shoes discount ugg boots is very Beautiful
boots ugg boots is very good
sale ugg boots on sale is very Comfortable
classic Ugg is very good
cheap Cheap Ugg is very Comfortable
shoes Cheap Uggs is very Beautiful
classic classic ugg boot is very good
very good classic ugg boots is very cheep
boots ugg classic short is Good quality
classic ugg classic short boots is very Comfortable
very classic ugg classic cardy is very good
very cardy classic cardy ugg boots is very Beautiful
classic cardy ugg classic cardy boots is very Comfortable

boots UGG Boots UK is Good quality
classic ugg boots sale is very Comfortable
very classic cheap ugg boots is very good
very cardy ugg boots is very Beautiful

shoes ugg is very Beautiful
boots cheap ugg is very good
sale cheap ugg boots is very Comfortable

good ugg boots sale cheap
good cheap ugg boots on sale
prefect discount ugg boots gift
tall ugg boots classic
women ugg boots on sale men
discount Ugg on sale
for sale Cheap Ugg good quality
cute Cheap Uggs nice

cardy ugg classic boot pink
good ugg classic boots online shop
nice ugg classic tall comfortable
beautiful ugg classic tall boots cardy
cheap classic tall ugg boots discount
comfortable ugg classic tall chestnut cheap

boots UGG Boots UK is Good quality
classic ugg boots sale is very Comfortable
very classic cheap ugg boots is very good
very cardy ugg boots is very Beautiful
Beautiful moncler jackets on sale
good moncler is online shop
for sale umoncler coats good quality

November 10, 2010 | Unregistered Commenterseo seo

You can find your dress here!!
wedding gowns
wedding gown
lace wedding gowns
wedding dresses
flower girls dresses

November 11, 2010 | Unregistered Commenterzeyan

http://www.goodgoodschina.com/

November 11, 2010 | Unregistered Commenterzeyan

The New Juicy Couture Bags are good for you to carry,and the new arrivals of Juicy Couture Dog Clothes on our Juicy Couture Outlet.

November 16, 2010 | Unregistered Commenterjuicy couture

Wearing the promotion price New Balance 1500 to enjoy the joy of running. That are all available at New Balance Outlet 24hrs online. New arrivals of New Balance are coming which save up 40% off.

November 16, 2010 | Unregistered Commenternew balance

A wide range of selection ugg uk online for you.http://www.uggsalebootsuk.com/

November 18, 2010 | Unregistered Commenterugg sale uk

This biography of the mens moncler down jacket three, although a German musician, an Italian sculptor, painter, poet, moncler jacket sale and the other is a Russian writer, each in different areas, but they are all great genius, in the life of hardship hardship of the journey,moncler vest sales to seek truth and justice, to create energy performance of truth, goodness and beauty of the immortal masterpieces, laid down their life energy.moncler vest jacket They believe that as long as their souls to perseverance and courage, not because of sorrow and calamity and indulge in destruction,moncler winter coats then it will be able to break the shackles of the flesh, toward the majestic heights of life.

November 18, 2010 | Unregistered Commentermoncler sale

Days are getting colder. Are you looking for a pair of great boots to keep your feet warm?The answer for you is UGG sale boots.The ugg boots on sale can make you feels like in spring always.The classic ugg boots on sale is the most famous of ugg boots sale.Also bailey ugg boots sale is popular one of ugg boots cheap.Cardy ugg boots sale are loved by girls too.It is fashionable sale cheap ugg boots.UGG boots sale cheap is most famous sheepskin boots on the world.It is popular for it's high quality and great design.Maybe you are planning to buy one pair of ugg boots discount.Good.But where to find ugg boots cheap sale?Here is a great ugg online store for you now.We provide you cheap ugg boots on sale.A great selection of cheapest ugg boots sale for you.What are you waiting for?Do not miss the chance,find your ugg boots cheap online here.UGG boots on sale cheap.ugg sale uk.ugg sale here.

November 29, 2010 | Unregistered Commenterugg boots cheap

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>